Skip to main content

Rants on Biased IPL Commentary!


Yet another long post on biased Broadcasting. Missing Harsha Bhogle Geoffrey Boycott

We grew up listening to Harsha Bhogle, Henry Blofeld, Geoffrey Boycott, Ian Chapel, Richie Benaud, Navjot Sidhu, Sunil Gavaskar, Rameez Raja , and Ravi Shastri. But I am afraid I cannot take names of the last three commentators in the same breath as I did the other cricketing analysts.

It’s okay if they kill you with their cricketing clichés like ‘In the end, Cricket is the winner’, ‘Form is temporary class is permanent’ etc; but as a presenter, if you take sides and start expressing them relentlessly in their views, then the cricket viewing experience is definitely adulterated and we will be forced to watch the game in mute mode. Here are some of the bloopers of the big three of Sunny Ravi and Rameez that I can recollect in the recently concluded VIVO IPL.

a) Eliminator 2, SRH vs GL, Sunny picks Gujarat Lions because they have as many as six impact players (including Sir Jadeja). He failed to mention the fact that the famed GL line up came a cropper twice in this very tournament against SRH bowling attack.

b) Rameez Raja is surprised when more educated and erudite viewers select SRH as the favorites to play RCB when they voted 61% and somehow reckoned that home tigers and Wasim led KKR had a better chance to qualify.

c) In the Finals, Warner was dismissed and there were three dot balls and Sunny Gavaskar goes gung-ho on the air saying “that’s what a wicket does, it dries up the boundaries” Just after three freaking balls!!! Befittingly Yuvraj shuts him up by taking on the RCB’star bowler for a four and a six in the very next over and a boundary in the beginning of another over.

d) Ravi Shastri, when Shane Watson starts the penultimate over with two wides and follows it up with two dot balls “This has been an exceptional over so far by Watson, it has pulled back the SRH”. Expectedly Watto concedes a four and a six in the remainder of the over along with few singles to take the tally of the ‘exceptional over’ to 16.

e) Rameez Raja in the Studio. These are two contrasting teams; “RCB is a balanced side, while SRH is riding on the high of a one-man army, its leader, David Warner”. One man army Rameez?? What about the purple cap holder, the emerging player of the IPL, big-game player Yuvraj, all-rounders, and MOTMs of Semi-Finals and Finals, Henriques and Cutting, Shikhar Dhawan, and useful contributions when it mattered from Deepak Hooda and Naman Ohja?

f) Sunil Gavaskar when the big three were dismissed, Rahul Watson & Abdulla also gone and Chris Jordan was batting and his sitter was dropped by Sran, Sunny exclaims “Did he just drop the Cup” Yes Sunny!! drop the cup when the entire starlet of RCB is back in the hut and an innocuous Jordan’s sitter was dropped and SRH drops the cup. Sunny Leone would have done more justice to his role there.

g) Watch for the reaction of Sunny when the two Ws were dismissed. The spirits that soared high when Warner was dismissed were depleted when Watson bowed out.

h) Finally when an improbable 37 were needed off 18 or something like that, Sunny still exclaims, “it’s not impossible, it has been done before”
That could have been the final nail in the coffin for a logical viewer, who relishes quality commentary as an integral part of cricket viewing experience. We had to bank on Danny Morrison, Pommie MBangwa, and Mathew Hayden and even Sanjay Manjrekar and Sidhu back in the studios and Sameer and Gaurav the anchors to get sanity to proceedings from these prejudiced views of the biggest scars of Indian Cricket, Gavaskar, and Shastri ably supported by their stooge, Raja.

In his younger and more refined days as a commentator, Sunny always used to say that he likes boundaries which keep the fielder interested till the end as he gets tired by chasing it. In a similar manner, I’m very glad that SRH did not knock their opponents out with a knockout punch but slowly and gradually decimated their challenge thereby killing the hopes of these misfiring commentators as many times.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review Late but true.... 3 Idiots!

My first post so nervous moments & here I go.... Having read Five Point someone, I was always worried at the idea of making a film out of that book completely starring Aamir Khan, given the youthful nature of the lead characters in the original plot. But after I saw the movie which was made with considerable amendments to the original plot and just keeping the main story intact, I was more than relieved with the thoughtful and refreshing changes that were made to the original plot. No this is not any attempt to indirectly support the VVC production house and query Chaitan Bhagat’s claims but it’s just a personal observation. But most of the good things to say about the movie unfortunately end here. Aamir Khan is of late playing roles where he is everything you want a lead role to be, confident, clear in thought, beyond materialistic pursuits of money and fame, always willing to forgive, forget and share his widespread knowledge & enlightening the lesser mortals; being spontaneo

A SOS on COC - Commodization of Cricket!

From early 2ks, ESS (EspnStar or then Star Sports) has been trying to advertise the game of cricket by glorifying the rivalry of any upcoming series.  Just that they chose to go the cinematic way of doing it than the accepted way of promoting a sporting event giving a brief history of its rivalry. Starting from LG ‘All the best, LG ki Duva’ to the 99 India Team that went to the World cup, to early 2ks, And the hope against hope, come on India, dikhado, India ko Jitado, when all we had was Sachin and ten duds to fill the 11 in those days. Badlaa (Australia V Pak) a revenge for Pak’s loss to Australia in WC-99 final. Barood (India v Aus) and Sarfarosh (Aus Pak India tri series), the campaign clearly did not yield the desired results.  Predictably, Aussies won the Badla and Barood Test series 6-0.They also won the tri series with the men in then light blue managing just one win from 8 games.  Much better was the world cup 2011, add where rope walkers from diffe

The God, Me & the Karmic Connection

Long post with back and forth screenplay & introspection & good luck if you read it through. A while ago, was on my way back home after taking care of some annual rituals. The road leading to the home was blocked by four back to back heavy vehicles and just in nick of time, I took a left turn so that the shorter cut can overtake the four heavy vehicles and the last Kilometre or so can be a smooth ride. A Wagon r also swiftly followed me and I had a fleeting pride of being a pioneer in adverse situations, I reached the end of the road in no time only to notice a ditch with varying measurements apparently dug in to stop the usage of the road. I promptly put aside my pioneer hat and donned the safety one, got down to gauge the width of the ditch and made a calculated assessment that the car would be safely negotiated if it's taken from the extreme right corner and tried the same, only to realize that the front left tyre was badly stuck in the Pit. When I